Team Culture

Why feedback from colleagues can be more valuable than manager feedback

Why feedback from colleagues can be more valuable than manager feedback

TL;DR

  • Colleagues and peers can offer unique insight into your performance that your manager might be oblivious to
  • Peers can provide more diverse and unbiased feedback
  • Feedback from peers is often less intimidating and more relatable
  • Frequent peer to peer feedback improves general team collaboration, because everyone is invested in each other’s growth
  • As part of your company culture, peer feedback increases accountability

Feedback is a powerful tool for personal and professional growth. Traditionally, we associate feedback with input from managers and superiors. While manager feedback is undoubtedly important, the value of feedback from colleagues or peers should not be underestimated. These are the 5 most important reasons why feedback from colleagues can be more valuable than from your manager.

Unique Insights into Your Performance

Your colleagues work closely with you on a daily basis, witnessing your performance in a way that your manager might not. They observe your strengths, weaknesses, and work habits in a more intimate setting, giving them unique insights into your professional capabilities. This enables them to offer feedback that is highly specific and actionable, tailored to various situations you encounter.

Diverse and Unbiased Feedback

Peers come from different backgrounds, experiences, and skill sets, which means their feedback is often more diverse and less influenced by hierarchical dynamics. Manager feedback can sometimes be affected by personal biases or pressures related to performance evaluations. Especially, if you ask for feedback proactively, colleagues are more likely to provide candid and objective feedback, ensuring a well-rounded perspective on your performance.

A Safe and Relatable Environment

Receiving feedback from managers can be daunting, particularly for employees who feel intimidated by the implications of their manager redirecting their behavior. In contrast, peer feedback tends to create a safer and more approachable environment. Colleagues understand the challenges you face, making it easier to accept their feedback and work towards improvement.

Fosters Team Collaboration

Frequent peer-to-peer feedback promotes a culture of collaboration within the team. When everyone is invested in each other's growth and success, it strengthens team dynamics and leads to a more cohesive and high-performing group. Continuous learning becomes an intrinsic part of the team's DNA, fostering team excellence.

Cultivates Accountability

Integrating peer feedback into your company culture enhances accountability among team members. Knowing that your peers will offer feedback can boost a sense of ownership and motivate you to perform at your best consistently. As a result, teams become more proactive, reliable, and committed to achieving collective goals.